« AB 920 Notices Due January 31A Look Back to Solar 2009 & A Look Ahead to 2010 »

3 Reasons Why Solar DIY is a Scam

01/04/10

Permalink 08:25:32 am, by Jim Jenal - Founder & CEO Email , 680 words   English (US) latin1
Categories: All About Solar Power, Solar News

Scam Warning - Why Solar is NOT a DIY Project

If you spend anytime at all reading information about solar energy on the Internet you will have come across one of those ads:

“Do it Yourself Solar!”
“Build Solar Panels at Home!" 
“Go Green and Save Green!”

and on and on. Sounds enticing - after all, who wouldn’t like to green up their life while saving money? But the scammers have you squarely in their sights and their do-it-yourself kits are a ripoff of your hard earned money.

At a minimum, there are at least three good reasons why solar is not a DIY project: 1) DC isn’t AC, 2) Safety, and 3) Utilities.

Let’s look at each one of these in turn.

DC isn’t AC - Solar panels produce direct current (DC), just like your car battery.  But the energy in your home is alternating current (AC) which reverses polarity 60 times a second.  Now a very few of the loads in your home won’t care - an incandescent light bulb will burn just fine with either AC or DC.  But your air conditioning system won’t.  Nor will your TV, your computer, your refrigerator, or nearly anything else that you own.  All of them are designed to operate on AC and running them on DC will either damage them, or do nothing at all.  Yet those are the things that drive your utility bill.  A $200, DIY solar panel (assuming for the sake of argument that such a thing can even be built) will do nothing to lower those bills.  So right off the bat, the huge $$$ savings promised are just that - a “pie-crust” promise - easily made, easily broken.

Safety - Quality solar panels sold in the United States are approved by Underwriters Laboratory (i.e., “UL Approved") for safety.  Since even a single solar panel can generate dangerous amounts of electricity, that approval provides peace of mind that the solar panels sitting on your roof will operate safely for the 25 years that you will own them.  Can the same be said for a DIY solar panel?  What if the unthinkable happens and your DIY solar panel malfunctions and starts a fire.  Will your homeowner’s insurance cover the loss after they learn that you placed solar panels on your roof that weren’t UL approved?  Is that a risk you want to take?

Utilities - If you are looking to lower your utility costs, you will need to connect your DIY system to the utility grid.  Before you can legally do that, your system has to have an inverter that meets not only UL approval but also the IEEE standard to prevent “islanding”.  The “anti-islanding” feature of a modern inverter is extremely important - here’s why.  A residential grid-tied solar power system is a small power plant connected remotely from the utility’s other power plants.  If a power line goes down, the utility will dispatch a crew to repair the break.  Before doing so, they will isolate that portion of the grid so that the lines are de-energized, allowing the workers to handle them safely.  But wait - they cannot isolate your mini power plant down the street which is acting as a power-generating island all unto itself.  That means the downed power line is still hot - and deadly.  To prevent such situations, “anti-islanding” technology is built into every grid-tied inverter sold in the U.S.  Building such an inverter is definitely not a DIY project, unless you are an electrical engineer.

Funny, but those ads never seem to talk about any of this.

Sure, we have a vested interest - we are in the business of installing high-quality, safe and reliable solar power systems.  But we aren’t worried here about losing a few sales.  Rather, we are worried about solar getting a bad reputation from hucksters and scammers souring people who were excited about the possibility of going solar, but got mislead and wasted their money and their time.

We believe - and have blogged about - the absolute right of consumers to be treated ethically by the solar industry.  We will continue to write about risks to that ethical standard, whether from conventional installers doing shoddy work (see here) or from rip-off artists and scammers like these.

Trackback address for this post

Trackback URL (right click and copy shortcut/link location)

6 comments

*****
Los Angeles tax attorneyIs the whole AC to DC issue the same when putting a wind turbine on top of one's roof?
01/13/10 @ 08:15
*****
Essentially, yes. While the turbine itself might produce AC, before you can connect that to the grid, you would need it to be controlled by a power conditioning unit that complies with UL 1741 to prevent islanding.
jpj
01/13/10 @ 08:25
Comment from: Jack [Visitor]
**---
JackHmm, okay so the "save a fortune with DIY solar" pitches are a scam. But what about the products themselves?

Assuming one knows what they are doing (solar cells installed on an outbuilding, a UL inverter, or no grid-tie at all), are the typical DIY products useful?
Most seem to be based on string-ribbon 3x6 solar cells putting out about 1.7W. There are a ton of these advertised on ebay, including "B" grade, and broken cells. Prices seem to go as low as 30c per watt, based on the specs, which seems to me to make solar almost a no-brainer in certain situations.
What about these cells and kits, do they actually work, is the output anywhere near spec, or are they selling cheap for a reason?
04/15/11 @ 22:50
Hi Jack - thanks for taking the time to comment.
If you are an advanced hobbyist who is able to test the performance of individual cells to control for performance variations and then assemble them into a waterproof, vibration proof structure (i.e., a panel) and then test that to make sure that it is electrically sound, and then repeat that process to produce the number of panels that you need, all the while making sure that the voltage, amperage and temperature characteristics of the assembled panels are within a reasonable tolerance, you will have taken the first step on building a DIY array.
Now you would need to hook those panels into an array, connect it to an inverter, mount everything to withstand the eventual wind loads and get it past an inspector. Then the utility will have a lot to say about what you are connecting to their grid.
This is just not something inexperienced people should be doing on their own. This is definitely "cheap for a reason."
04/16/11 @ 06:43
Comment from: Lee Cordochorea [Visitor]
****-
Lee CordochoreaDo the math. You can't get individual cells for less than about $5 per watt. You CAN get complete panels for about $5 per watt in the $150 - $200 range. For 2x or 3x that price range, you can get panels for less than $3 per watt!

When someone says they have no technical expertise, WHY should we listen to their technical advice? And WHY O WHY should we PAY them for technical advice?
08/12/11 @ 21:26
Lee -
Part of the problem is the people promoting this stuff are targeting people who aren't really technical themselves and DON'T do math!
Point well taken - and thanks for taking the time to comment. This continues to be one of the most read posts we have ever done!

Jim
08/13/11 @ 08:53

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.
PoorExcellent
(Line breaks become <br />)
(For my next comment on this site)
(Allow users to contact me through a message form -- Your email will not be revealed!)
Jim Jenal is the Founder & CEO of Run on Sun, Pasadena's premier installer and integrator of top-of-the-line solar power installations.
In addition, Run on Sun offers solar consulting services, working with consumers, utilities and municipalities to help them make solar power affordable and reliable.

Call Now - (626) 793-6025 or

Click here to Visit Our Site

Free Run on Sun Solar Site Evaluation - Click here